VLA CASA Bandpass Slope-CASA4.5.2
This CASA Guide is for CASA version 4.5.2
For the standard VLA flux density calibrators 3C138, 3C147, 3C286, and 3C48, CASA includes a spatial and spectral model that is applied for bandpass calibration. This model removed the source characteristics, resulting in a calibration solution that is a representation of the instrumental and atmospheric corrections. These VLA standard calibrators, however, exhibit a negative spectral index and are relatively weak at high frequencies.
Although the standard VLA flux density calibrators are usually still bright enough for absolute flux density calibration, a good bandpass determination—which is very important for spectral line observations—requires large signal-to-noise ratios derived from either a long integration time or a very strong source (see the Spectral Line Guide for Observing). Observations of non-standard, but strong, bandpass calibrators are therefore common at high frequencies. Unfortunately, such sources are likely variable and no a priori flux density model is available. In particular, these sources exhibit an unknown and maybe variable spectral slope, which, if not accounted for, will create an error in the bandpass calibration. This tutorial describes how to model a spectral slope and how to correct the bandpass solution for this effect.
Data used in this guide are taken in wide 3-bit mode for the protostar G192.16-3.84 in Ka-band with basebands centered at 29 and 36.5 GHz. Each baseband has over 4 GHz of bandwidth comprising thirty-two 128-MHz spectral windows.
If you are new to CASA, or with VLA data reduction in CASA, it is strongly recommended that you start with either the EVLA Continuum Tutorial 3C391 or Getting Started in CASA before proceeding with this tutorial.
Obtaining the Data
As this tutorial concerns bandpass calibration, all sources other than the flux density and bandpass calibrator scans were removed from the MS. All pre-calibration steps including flagging, antenna position offsets, requantizer gains, opacity corrections, and gain-elevation curves were applied. The original data (TVER0004.sb14459364.eb14492359.56295.26287841435) can be obtained through the NRAO archive and has a raw size of 57.04 GB.
The trimmed measurement set can be downloaded directly from http://casa.nrao.edu/Data/EVLA/G192/G192-BP.ms.tar.gz (dataset size: 3.4 GB)
Your first step will be to unzip and untar the file in a terminal (before you start CASA):
tar -xzvf G192-BP.ms.tar.gz
To start CASA, type:
This will run a script initializing CASA and setting paths appropriately. The script will also create two files called ipython-<unique-stamp>.log (which contains a record of all the text you enter at the CASA prompt) as well as casapy-<unique-stamp>.log (which will contain all the messages that are printed to the CASA logger window). It is recommended that you keep your log files intact—you may need them to remind you of the last step you completed in your data reduction. (It is also a good idea to include your log files when submitting a help desk ticket).
Once CASA has started, a logger window will appear. Note that you can rescale this window or change the font size (under the View menu option) as desired.
Examining the Measurement Set (MS)
We use listobs to summarize our MS:
# In CASA: listobs on the initial data set listobs('G192-BP.ms', listfile='G192_listobs.txt')
This will write the output to a file called G192_listobs.txt, which we can print to the terminal using various Unix/Linux commands such as cat, less, or more:
# In CASA cat G192_listobs.txt
================================================================================ MeasurementSet Name: /lustre/aoc/sciops/jott/casa/topicalguide/bandpass/new/G192-BP.ms MS Version 2 ================================================================================ Observer: Dr. Debra Shepherd Project: uid://evla/pdb/7303457 Observation: EVLA Data records: 1769355 Total elapsed time = 4563 seconds Observed from 03-Jan-2013/06:31:48.0 to 03-Jan-2013/07:47:51.0 (UTC) ObservationID = 0 ArrayID = 0 Date Timerange (UTC) Scan FldId FieldName nRows SpwIds Average Interval(s) ScanIntent 03-Jan-2013/06:31:48.0 - 06:36:42.0 6 0 3C147 704865 [0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61,62,63] [6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 5.94, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6] [CALIBRATE_FLUX#UNSPECIFIED,OBSERVE_TARGET#UNSPECIFIED] 07:40:27.0 - 07:47:51.0 64 1 3c84-J0319+413 1064490 [0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63] [6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6, 6] [CALIBRATE_BANDPASS#UNSPECIFIED,OBSERVE_TARGET#UNSPECIFIED] (nRows = Total number of rows per scan) Fields: 2 ID Code Name RA Decl Epoch SrcId nRows 0 E 3C147 05:42:36.137916 +49.51.07.23356 J2000 0 704865 1 F 3c84-J0319+413 03:19:48.160102 +220.127.116.1105 J2000 1 1064490 Spectral Windows: (64 unique spectral windows and 1 unique polarization setups) SpwID Name #Chans Frame Ch0(MHz) ChanWid(kHz) TotBW(kHz) CtrFreq(MHz) BBC Num Corrs 0 EVLA_KA#A1C1#2 128 TOPO 34476.000 1000.000 128000.0 34539.5000 10 RR LL 1 EVLA_KA#A1C1#3 128 TOPO 34604.000 1000.000 128000.0 34667.5000 10 RR LL 2 EVLA_KA#A1C1#4 128 TOPO 34732.000 1000.000 128000.0 34795.5000 10 RR LL 3 EVLA_KA#A1C1#5 128 TOPO 34860.000 1000.000 128000.0 34923.5000 10 RR LL <snip> 13 EVLA_KA#A1C1#15 128 TOPO 36140.000 1000.000 128000.0 36203.5000 10 RR LL 14 EVLA_KA#A1C1#16 128 TOPO 36268.000 1000.000 128000.0 36331.5000 10 RR LL 15 EVLA_KA#A1C1#17 128 TOPO 36396.000 1000.000 128000.0 36459.5000 10 RR LL 16 EVLA_KA#A2C2#18 128 TOPO 36476.000 1000.000 128000.0 36539.5000 11 RR LL 17 EVLA_KA#A2C2#19 128 TOPO 36604.000 1000.000 128000.0 36667.5000 11 RR LL 18 EVLA_KA#A2C2#20 128 TOPO 36732.000 1000.000 128000.0 36795.5000 11 RR LL <snip> 29 EVLA_KA#A2C2#31 128 TOPO 38140.000 1000.000 128000.0 38203.5000 11 RR LL 30 EVLA_KA#A2C2#32 128 TOPO 38268.000 1000.000 128000.0 38331.5000 11 RR LL 31 EVLA_KA#A2C2#33 128 TOPO 38396.000 1000.000 128000.0 38459.5000 11 RR LL 32 EVLA_KA#B1D1#34 128 TOPO 26976.000 1000.000 128000.0 27039.5000 13 RR LL 33 EVLA_KA#B1D1#35 128 TOPO 27104.000 1000.000 128000.0 27167.5000 13 RR LL 34 EVLA_KA#B1D1#36 128 TOPO 27232.000 1000.000 128000.0 27295.5000 13 RR LL <snip> 45 EVLA_KA#B1D1#47 128 TOPO 28640.000 1000.000 128000.0 28703.5000 13 RR LL 46 EVLA_KA#B1D1#48 128 TOPO 28768.000 1000.000 128000.0 28831.5000 13 RR LL 47 EVLA_KA#B1D1#49 128 TOPO 28896.000 1000.000 128000.0 28959.5000 13 RR LL 48 EVLA_KA#B2D2#50 128 TOPO 28976.000 1000.000 128000.0 29039.5000 14 RR LL 49 EVLA_KA#B2D2#51 128 TOPO 29104.000 1000.000 128000.0 29167.5000 14 RR LL 50 EVLA_KA#B2D2#52 128 TOPO 29232.000 1000.000 128000.0 29295.5000 14 RR LL <snip> 61 EVLA_KA#B2D2#63 128 TOPO 30640.000 1000.000 128000.0 30703.5000 14 RR LL 62 EVLA_KA#B2D2#64 128 TOPO 30768.000 1000.000 128000.0 30831.5000 14 RR LL 63 EVLA_KA#B2D2#65 128 TOPO 30896.000 1000.000 128000.0 30959.5000 14 RR LL Sources: 128 ID Name SpwId RestFreq(MHz) SysVel(km/s) 0 3C147 0 - - 0 3C147 1 - - 0 3C147 2 - - <snip> 0 3C147 61 - - 0 3C147 62 - - 0 3C147 63 - - 1 3c84-J0319+413 0 - - 1 3c84-J0319+413 1 - - 1 3c84-J0319+413 2 - - <snip> 1 3c84-J0319+413 61 - - 1 3c84-J0319+413 62 - - 1 3c84-J0319+413 63 - - <snip>
We have trimmed the MS to contain only scans on the flux calibrator 3C147 (field 0) and the bandpass calibrator 3C84 (field 1) but retained all 64 spectral windows, each 128 MHz wide and containing one hundred twenty-eight 1 MHz channels.
Setting the Model of the Flux Density Calibrator
To start, we insert the spectral (using the 'Perley-Butler 2013' standard) and spatial (3C147_A.im for Ka-band) models for the flux density calibrator 3C147 (field 0) with the setjy task:
# In CASA: model for the flux density calibrator setjy(vis='G192-BP.ms', field='0', scalebychan=True, \ standard='Perley-Butler 2013', model='3C147_A.im')
- scalebychan=True: If scalebychan=False setjy would use a single value per spectral window.
Inspecting the logger report shows that 3C147 has a flux density ranging from ~1.0-1.47 Jy across all spws.
We can plot the model data using plotms (Figure 1):
# In CASA plotms(vis='G192-BP.ms', field='0', antenna='ea03', \ xaxis='freq', yaxis='amp', ydatacolumn='model',coloraxis='ant2')
This plot shows baselines to antenna ea03. Since we provided both a spectral and a spatial model for this well resolved calibrator, each baseline has a somewhat different behavior.
Calibrating delays and initial bandpass solutions
As a first step, we need to specify a reference antenna for all phase calibrations. It is desirable to use an antenna that is near the center of the array and that has a minimum of flags. The array can be mapped with plotants:
# In CASA: plotting antenna locations plotants(vis='G192-BP.ms')
Although the plot is a bit crowded (Figure 2), a zooming in (the icon with the magnifying glass) shows that ea05 sits close to the center and appears to be a good choice.
We start with a phase-only calibration solution on a narrow range of channels near the center of each spectral window on the bandpass calibrator 3C84. We select a narrow range of channels near the center to flatten with respect to time before solving for the bandpass. This action will remove most of the decorrelation of the signal. The channel range of 60~68 should work, and we want derive a solution for each individual integration:
# In CASA: phase only calibration gaincal(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.G0', \ field='1', spw='*:60~68', \ gaintype='G', refant='ea05', calmode='p', \ solint='int', minsnr=3)
- refant='ea05' : Use ea05 as the reference antenna
- solint='int' : Do a per-integration solve (every 6 seconds, since we've time-averaged the data).
- minsnr=3 : Apply a minimum signal-to-noise cutoff. Solutions with less than this value will be flagged.
- gaintable is not set here as we have already applied pre-calibrations.
Plot the phase solutions (using full phase range -180 to 180 instead of autorange):
# In CASA plotcal(caltable='calG192.G0', xaxis='time', yaxis='phase', \ iteration='antenna', plotrange=[-1,-1,-180,180])
Click on the Next button to navigate through the antennas. Click on the Quit button to exit the viewer.
We will now produce multipanel plots of the phase solutions, writing the plots to output files as well as on the screen (Figures 3a & 3b). The output files generated are PNG files and can be viewed within CASA by executing an external viewer program, e.g., !xv plotG192_plotcal_G0p1.png; or by running any number of image viewing applications such as xv, Preview, Gimp, Photoshop, etc., external to CASA at the OS level.
# In CASA plotcal(caltable='calG192.G0', xaxis='time', yaxis='phase', \ antenna='0~10,12~15', subplot=531, iteration='antenna', \ plotrange=[-1,-1,-180,180], fontsize=8.0, \ markersize=3.0, figfile='plotG192_plotcal_G0p1.png') plotcal(caltable='calG192.G0', xaxis='time', yaxis='phase', \ antenna='16~26', subplot=531, iteration='antenna', \ plotrange=[-1,-1,-180,180], fontsize=8.0, \ markersize=3.0, figfile='plotG192_plotcal_G0p2.png')
We can now solve for the residual delays using the gaintype='K' option in gaincal. Note that this currently does not do a global fringe-fitting solution for delays, but instead does a baseline-based delay solution per spw for all baselines to the reference antenna, treating these as antenna-based delays. In most cases, with high enough S/N to get baseline-based delay solutions, this will suffice. We avoid the edge channels of each spectral window by selecting channels 5~122:
# In CASA: residual delays gaincal(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.K0', \ field='1', spw='*:5~122', gaintype='K', \ gaintable=['calG192.G0'], refant='ea05', solint='inf', minsnr=3)
Note that we have also pre-applied our initial phase table calG192.G0.
Alternatively, you can also derive a delay across all spws of a baseband. If this is desired, use combine='spw' in gaincal and run the task for each baseband separately. The solutions from the second and following runs can be appended to the same calibration table via append=T.
Now plot the delays, in nanoseconds, as a function of antenna index (you will get one for each spw and polarization):
# In CASA plotcal(caltable='calG192.K0', xaxis='antenna', yaxis='delay')
The delays range from around -5 to 4 nanoseconds (Figure 4).
Now solve for the antenna bandpasses using the previously generated tables calG192.G0 and calG192.K0:
# In CASA: antenna bandpasses bandpass(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.B0', \ gaintable=['calG192.G0', 'calG192.K0'], \ field='1', refant='ea05', solnorm=False, \ bandtype='B', solint='inf')
WARNING: You must set solnorm=False here or later on you will find some offsets among spws due to the way the amplitude scaling adjusts weights internally during solving.
You will see in the terminal window some reports of solutions failing due to "Insufficient unflagged antennas"—note that these are for bad channels that have been pre-flagged.
Plot the resulting bandpasses in amplitude and phase. Note that the first panel with ea01 is empty as it is completely flagged. Proceed to ea06 to see the plots as shown in Figures 5a, 5b, 6a, and 6b:
# In CASA plotcal(caltable='calG192.B0', xaxis='freq', yaxis='amp', \ spw='0~31', iteration='antenna') # plotcal(caltable='calG192.B0', xaxis='freq', yaxis='amp', \ spw='32~63', iteration='antenna') # plotcal(caltable='calG192.B0', xaxis='freq', yaxis='phase', \ iteration='antenna', spw='0~31', \ plotrange=[-1,-1,-180,180]) # plotcal(caltable='calG192.B0', xaxis='freq', yaxis='phase', \ iteration='antenna', spw='32~63', \ plotrange=[-1,-1,-180,180])
Bootstrapping the bandpass calibrator spectrum
Since there is no a priori spectral information for our chosen bandpass calibrator—3C84—we need to bootstrap to find its spectral index, then recalibrate with this information in order to avoid folding the intrinsic spectral shape of 3C84 into our calibration.
First, we again do a phase-only calibration solution, this time for both the bandpass and the flux density calibrator. This will correct for decorrelation of the signals. Again we use the channel range 60~68 and apply the bandpass and delay calibration tables:
# In CASA: flux and bandpass calibrators gain gaincal(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.G1p', field='0,1', \ gaintable=['calG192.K0', 'calG192.B0'], \ gaintype='G', refant='ea05', calmode='p', solint='int', minsnr=3)
Now we are ready to solve for both, phase and gain for each scan:
# In CASA: flux and bandpass calibrators gain gaincal(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.G1', field='0,1', \ gaintable=['calG192.K0', 'calG192.B0','calG192.G1p'], \ gaintype='G', refant='ea05', calmode='ap', solint='inf', minsnr=3)
With gain solutions for the flux density and bandpass calibrators, we can now use fluxscale to scale the gain amplitudes of the bandpass calibrator using those of the flux density calibrator:
# In CASA: bandpass calibrator gain amplitudes scaling flux1 = fluxscale(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.G1', \ fluxtable='calG192.F1', reference='0', \ transfer='1', listfile='3C84.fluxinfo', fitorder=1)
- flux1 = fluxscale(...): we allow fluxscale to use the variable flux1 for the output Python dictionary that is returned, which has information about the flux scaling. You can inspect the output dictionary flux1 by typing "print flux1" at the CASA command line.
- fluxtable='calG192.F1': this is the output scaled gain table. Since we are only using this to find the spectral index of 3C84, we won't be using this table.
- listfile='3C84.fluxinfo': an output file that contains the derived flux values and fit information.
- fitorder=1: only find a spectral index, ignoring curvature in the spectrum.
- reference='0': the reference field from which the flux scaling is transferred (here: the flux calibrator 3C147, field 0)
- transfer='1': the target field to which the flux scaling is transferred (here: the bandpass calibrator 3C84, field 1)
The last line in the file (and displayed in the logger) shows:
Fitted spectrum for 3c84-J0319+413 with fitorder=1: Flux density = 29.0282 +/- 0.0308648 (freq=32.5128 GHz) spidx=-0.538758 +/- 0.00882913
Using the information in the returned flux1 dictionary, we can plot the derived spectrum (Figure 7):
# In CASA freq = flux1['freq'] / 1e9 spw_list = range(0,64) spw_str =  for i in spw_list: thisspw = str(i) spw_str.append(thisspw)
# In CASA bootstrapped_fluxes =  for j in spw_str: thisflux = flux1['1'][j]['fluxd'] if thisflux ==None: continue else: bootstrapped_fluxes.append(thisflux)
# In CASA - this section creates the plot seen in Figure 7 pl.clf() pl.plot(freq, bootstrapped_fluxes, 'bo') pl.xlabel('Frequency (GHz)') pl.ylabel('Flux Density (Jy)') pl.title('3C84') pl.show()
We can use the model from fluxscale to fill the MODEL column with 3C84's spectral information using setjy. With standard='fluxscale', we can directly use the flux1 Python dictionary as input via fluxdict:
# In CASA: spectral information setjy(vis='G192-BP.ms', field='1', scalebychan=True, \ standard = 'fluxscale', fluxdict=flux1)
Checking with plotms that the data have been appropriately filled (Figure 8):
# In CASA plotms(vis='G192-BP.ms', field='1', antenna='ea05&ea02', \ xaxis='freq', yaxis='amp', ydatacolumn='model')
We redo the previous calibration using this new model information. Although the commands are the same as what we issued earlier, keep in mind that the model values for the bandpass calibrator have changed, and therefore the results of these calibration calculations will differ:
# In CASA: phase only recalibration gaincal(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.G0.b', \ field='1', spw='*:60~68', \ gaintype='G', refant='ea05', calmode='p', \ solint='int', minsnr=3) # In CASA: residual delays recalibration gaincal(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.K0.b', \ gaintable=['calG192.G0.b'], \ field='1', spw='*:5~122', gaintype='K', \ refant='ea05', solint='inf', minsnr=3) # In CASA: antenna bandpasses recalibration bandpass(vis='G192-BP.ms', caltable='calG192.B0.b', \ gaintable=['calG192.G0.b', 'calG192.K0.b'], \ field='1', refant='ea05', solnorm=False, \ bandtype='B', solint='inf')
Finally we inspect these solutions (Figures 9a, 9b, 10a, and 10b):
# In CASA - Figure 9a plotcal(caltable='calG192.B0.b', xaxis='freq', yaxis='amp', \ spw='0~31', iteration='antenna') # Figure 9b plotcal(caltable='calG192.B0.b', xaxis='freq', yaxis='amp', \ spw='32~63', iteration='antenna') # Figure 10a plotcal(caltable='calG192.B0.b', xaxis='freq', yaxis='phase', \ iteration='antenna', spw='0~31', \ plotrange=[-1,-1,-180,180]) # Figure 10b plotcal(caltable='calG192.B0.b', xaxis='freq', yaxis='phase', \ iteration='antenna', spw='32~63', \ plotrange=[-1,-1,-180,180])
They look virtually unchanged from the previous solutions, with the exception that the amplitude scaling is corrected for the spectrum of 3C84. Now that we have the final version of our delay and bandpass calibration tables, calG192.K0.b and calG192.B0.b can be used for all subsequent calibration steps.
Last checked on CASA Version 4.5.2